NBC Presents: Best Plays

was "a series of hour-length dramas based on famous theatrical books begun by the late Burns Mantle, now edited by the distinguished drama critic of the New York Daily News, John Chapman." --- from the intro.

Sources used to create my own log and double-check titles, dates and cast members: Digital Deli Too, RadioGOLDINdex, and Internet Speculative Fiction Database and John Chapman's introduction to each episode.

Currently this archive contains 4 of 52 plotlines and 4 reviews

Webmaster Recommends:
Angel Street | On Borrowed Time

Accent on Youth

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Samson Raphaelson

Reviews:

All My Sons

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: N
Story by: Arthur Miller

Reviews:

Amazing Dr Clitterhouse, The

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Barré Lyndon

Reviews:

Angel Street

aka: "Gas Light"
Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre: Psychological Thriller
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Patrick Hamilton

London, 1880. Bella Manningham is losing her mind. She misplaces her jewelry and grocery bills; she removes paintings from the walls and forgets where she puts them and can't even remember removing them in the first place; she imagines the gas lights dimming in the evening... Jack, her husband, threatens to lock her in her room... alone and in the dark... if she doesn't straighten herself out. This doesn't seem to help.

With Vincent Price (Jack Manningham), Judith Evelyn (Bella Manningham), and Melville Cooper (Detective Rough).

"Somehow I hesitate to describe the Best Play we are presenting here as a 'psychological melodrama', because that phrase doesn't have the punch it used to have. It seems to me that it used to mean a play or a movie that was enormously exciting, but still intelligent. It was a thriller that made sense and didn't have to rely on sliding panels, clutching claws and all of the other machinery of the old-time [maller?]. But what I've seen lately, on the stage at least and a good bit of the time in the movies, a psychological melodrama is a melodrama in which nothing happens. Since nothing has happened, I go right home to bed and sleep like a practically toothless baby. But that wasn't the case on the night of December 5th, 1941, when I saw the first performance of Patrick Hamilton's 'Angel Street'. A great deal happened in that play, even though it was psychological. It was so psychological, in fact, that it kept my head whirling for hours. What a cunning and cruel devil that Mr Manningham was. And how clever was that very dull looking man from Scotland Yard, Sergeant Rough. And what a terrible time that frail, beautiful, Mrs Manningham had. This was indeed a Best Play." --- John Chapman

Reviews:
Equal parts psychological suspense and psychological abuse, this gripping tale relies heavily on the performance of the three main characters: Vincent Price, Judith Evelyn, and Melville Cooper. Price and Evelyn reprise their Broadway roles, with Evelyn playing a frail woman slowly sinking into madness while Price plays her husband who may, or may not, be deliberately driving her so. Cooper plays the shrewd and calculating former detective who is looking into past irregularities. Solid acting all around. [8/10] --- zM

Another Language

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Rose Franken

Reviews:

Arsenic and Old Lace

aka: "Bodies in Our Cellar"
Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre: Black Comedy
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Joseph Kesselring

With Boris Karloff.

Reviews:

Autumn Crocus

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Dodie Smith as C.L. Anthony

Reviews:

Bell for Adano, A

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: John Hersey

Reviews:

Biography

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: S.N. Behrman

Reviews:

Blithe Spirit

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre: Ghosts, Humour
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Noël Coward

John Loder is a writer researching material for a mystery novel. As a lark, he invites the eccentric medium, Madame Arcati, to hold a séance. It's great fun... until Madame Arcati inadvertently materializes Loder's first wife, Elvira! Further complications arise when Elvira refuses to return to the 'other side' and seems intent on disrupting Loder's current marriage.

With John Loder (Charles Condomine), Mildred Natwick (Ruth), Haila Stoddard (Elvira), and Anne Burr (Madame Arcati).

Reviews:
A well-written light comedy with good characterization and dialogue. Humorous and enjoyable. [6/10] --- zM

Bound East for Cardiff

Year: 1952
Duration: 30 min ??
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: N
Story by: Eugene O'Neill

Aired with "The Long Voyage Home", also by Eugene O'Neill.

Reviews:

Camille

aka: "La Dame aux Camélias"
aka: "The Lady of the Camellias"
Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Alexandre Dumas, fils

Reviews:

Craig's Wife

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: George Edward Kelly

Reviews:

Dark of the Moon, The

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre: Fantasy
Available for Listening Booth: N
Story by: traditional

A dramatization by Howard Richardson and William Berney of the centuries-old European folk song "The Ballad of Barbara Allen".

See also: "The Death of Barbara Allen" (Suspense).

Reviews:

Detective Story

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Sidney Kingsley

Reviews:

Elizabeth the Queen

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Maxwell Anderson

Reviews:

Ethan Frome

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Edith Wharton

Reviews:

Farmer Takes a Wife, The

aka: "Rome Haul"
Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre: Adventure
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Walter D. Edmonds

A 1934 play by Frank B. Elser and Marc Connelly based on the novel Rome Haul by Walter D. Edmonds.

With Joan Lorring.

Reviews:

Glass Menagerie, The

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: N
Story by: Tennessee Williams

Reviews:

Hasty Heart, The

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre: Romantic Comedy
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: John Patrick

Burma, 1943. Patients in the convalescent ward of an army field hospital try to make a dying Scot's last days happy and contented, but the hard-headed Scot—who doesn't know his kidney is failing—resists all attempts at friendship.

With John Sylvester (Lachie—soldier) and Anne Burr (Margaret—nurse).

"This Best Play we are about to do for you isn't exactly a War play, but it's a comedy with a war background. The year it was produced, 1945, brought us another good comedy with a war background. This was John Hersey's 'A Bell for Adano'. Our play, 'The Hasty Heart' did very well alongside such other new successes besides 'Adano' as 'Harvey' and 'The Glass Menagerie'... 'The Hasty Heart' is about a soldier who was in a hospital somewhere back of the China/Burma/India front and a nurse who was a gallant little girl and an interesting assortment of fellow patients." --- John Chapman

Reviews:

High Tor

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Maxwell Anderson

Reviews:

Home of the Brave

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Laurents, Arthur

Reviews:

John Loves Mary

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Krasna, Norman

Reviews:

Kiss the Boys Goodbye

Year: 1953; 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Clare Boothe Luce

Reviews:

Ladies in Retirement

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: N
Story by: Reginald Denham and Edward Percy Smith

Another version was produced for Theatre Guild on the Air.

Reviews:

Long Voyage Home, The

Year: 1952
Duration: 30 min ??
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: N
Story by: Eugene O'Neill

Aired with "Bound East for Cardiff", also by Eugene O'Neill.

Reviews:

Macbeth

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: William Shakespeare

Reviews:

Madwoman Of Chaillot, The

aka: "La Folle de Chaillot"
Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Jean Giraudoux

Reviews:

Male Animal, The

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: James Thurber and Elliott Nugent

Reviews:

Men in White

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Sidney Kingsley

Reviews:

Missouri Legend

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Elizabeth Beall Ginty

A Tale about Jesse James.

Reviews:

Mister Roberts

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Thomas Heggen

Reviews:

Night Must Fall

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Emlyn Williams

Wealthy old Mrs Bramson hires charming young Danny as a companion, but her niece suspects him of being a murderer.

Reviews:
An arch, unthreatening Alfred Drake isn't nearly as charismatic a psychopath as Robert Montgomery in the Suspense version or James Cagney in the Screen Guild abbreviation; and Mary Boland is no Dame May Whitty (who captured both the monstrousness and the pathos of Mrs. Bramson); and George Lefferts' adaptation is flat, lacks suspense, and shortchanges the ambivalence that gives the niece's character so much interest. On the plus side, Horace Braham plays exactly the same sort of smooth Scotland Yard detective he played on Wyllis Cooper's Whitehall 1212 (a minor treat, if you're a fan of that series). But the 1937 film (with Montgomery, Whitty, and Rosalind Russell) is still better than all the vintage radio versions put together. --- Anonymous

Of Mice and Men

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: John Steinbeck

Reviews:

On Borrowed Time

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre: Speculative
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Lawrence Edward Watkin

Fiercely independent Gramps refuses to accompany Death when he comes calling. Meanwhile, manipulative Aunt Demetria, offended at the way young Pud idolizes Gramps and mimics his uncouth behaviour, manoeuvres to gain custody over Pud so he can be raised as a proper Christian. The result is a battle of wills between Gramps, Aunt Demetria... and Death.

With Parker Fennelly (Julian Northrup—gramps), Mildred Natwick (Nellie Northrup—granny), and David Anderson (Pud).

Another version was produced for the Theatre Guild on the Air.

"For myself, the test of a fine play or a fine performance is a simple one: after I've seen it, do I want to stay up half the night, or maybe all the night, talking about it? That's just what happened to me on the cold evening of February 3rd, 1938. I was too excited to sleep, for I'd just seen the first performance of Paul Osborn's 'On Borrowed Time'. Here was a beautiful play, brimful of humour and affection. It was one of the Best Plays of that season, and it's one of the best for you, now." --- John Chapman

Reviews:
A slow-moving tale—sad and melancholy in parts, but humorous and tender in others—which dramatizes the necessity for death, without resorting to melodrama or histrionics. Audio quality is superb. The acting is generally good, but what really makes this story work is the interaction between Gramps (abrupt and snappy, yet tender) and his grandson, Pud (impressionable, wide-eyed, and innocent). Gramps clearly cares a lot for Pud, but he's not the type to express such thoughts. [8/10] --- zM

Outward Bound

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Sutton Vane

Reviews:

Petrified Forest, The

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Robert E. Sherwood

Reviews:

Philadelphia Story, The

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Philip Barry

Reviews:

Rope

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Patrick Hamilton

Reviews:

Rose Tattoo, The

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Tennessee Williams

Reviews:

She Loves Me Not

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Edward Hope

Reviews:

Skylark

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Samson Raphaelson

Reviews:

St Helena

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: R.C. Sherriff and Jeanne de Casalis

Reviews:

Summer and Smoke

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Tennessee Williams

Reviews:

Susan and God

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Rachel Crothers

Reviews:

There Shall Be No Night

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Robert E. Sherwood

Reviews:

There's Always Juliet

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: John van Druten

Reviews:

Tonight at 8:30

Year: 1953
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Noël Coward

Reviews:

Uncle Harry

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Thomas Job

Reviews:

Victoria Regina

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Laurence Housman

Reviews:

Voice of the Turtle, The

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre:
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: John van Druten

Reviews:

Winterset

Year: 1952
Duration: 60 min
Genre: Verse Drama; Tragedy
Available for Listening Booth: Y
Story by: Maxwell Anderson

A young man (Mio Romagna) believes his father was wrongly executed for a murder he didn't commit. His search for truth and justice take him to a tenement on New York's East River where he falls in love with a young woman (Miriamne Esdras) and discovers her family may know more about the murder than they are willing to admit.

With Burgess Meredith (Mio Romagna) and Maureen Stapleton (Miriamne Esdras).

"You may remember that Winterset was first produced in the fall of 1935. That was a good year in the theatre, and there was a new group calling itself the 'New York Drama Critic's Circle'. The circle was going to give a prize to the best play of that year, and this [?] time. Up till then, nobody thought that one drama critic could agree with another one on anything. But the critics circle came out of its huddle quite happily and announced that its very first prize was going to Maxwell Anderson for 'Winterset'." --- John Chapman

Reviews: